Your GA4 dashboard went from showing 10,000 monthly visitors to 500 overnight—and you didn’t change anything. On July 21, 2025, Google silently began enforcing Consent Mode V2 for all EEA and UK traffic. No warning email. No deprecation notice. Just a 90-95% drop in metrics for thousands of WordPress stores whose consent banners looked compliant but weren’t actually transmitting signals to Google tags.

What Consent Mode V2 Enforcement Actually Broke#

The worst part? Data from non-compliant periods is permanently lost. There’s no backfill. No recovery. No “sorry, here’s your data back.” Every day your consent configuration stays broken is data you’ll never see again.

Why Cookie Banners Alone Don’t Work#

Here’s what most WordPress store owners got wrong: they installed a cookie consent plugin, saw a nice-looking banner appear, and assumed they were compliant. The banner shows “Accept” and “Reject” buttons. It blocks cookies until consent is given. It looks exactly like every other GDPR-compliant site.

But looking compliant and being compliant are different things.

Consent Mode V2 requires your banner to actively communicate consent states to Google tags through specific parameters: ad_storage, analytics_storage, ad_user_data, and ad_personalization. When a visitor clicks “Accept” or “Reject,” your consent management platform must transmit these signals to GA4 and GTM in real-time.

Many popular WordPress consent plugins—CookieBot, Complianz, CookieYes—can do this. But “can” doesn’t mean “configured to.” The default installation of most consent plugins shows a compliant-looking banner that doesn’t actually transmit consent signals to anything. The banner works visually. The integration to Google tags doesn’t exist unless you explicitly set it up.

You may be interested in: Google Consent Mode v2 Is Killing Your Analytics

What July 21, 2025 Actually Changed#

Before enforcement, GA4 collected data regardless of consent configuration. You’d see warnings in your interface about Consent Mode not being detected, but data still flowed. Google was patient. They gave warnings. They sent documentation.

Then they stopped being patient.

After July 21, 2025, GA4 completely stops collecting data from EEA and UK visitors if it doesn’t receive proper consent signals. Not reduced data. Not sampled data. Zero data. Your European traffic—often 30-50% of a WooCommerce store’s visitors—simply vanishes from reports.

The enforcement was silent. Google didn’t send mass emails announcing the exact date. Store owners discovered the change when they opened their dashboards and saw cliffs in their traffic graphs. According to reports in Google Analytics community forums, 90-95% metric drops were common for sites that hadn’t properly integrated consent signals (Google Analytics Community, 2025).

The Behavioral Modeling Trap#

Google’s solution to consent-related data loss is behavioral modeling—machine learning that estimates data from users who denied consent based on patterns from users who accepted. In theory, this fills the gaps. In practice, it doesn’t work for most small stores.

GA4’s behavioral modeling requires 1,000+ daily events from BOTH consenting AND denying users for 7 consecutive days (Google Analytics Documentation, 2025). This threshold exists because the model needs sufficient data from both groups to make accurate predictions.

Here’s the problem: a WooCommerce store with 200 daily visitors and a 60% consent rejection rate has roughly 80 consenting visitors generating events. Even if every visitor triggers 5 events, that’s 400 consented events—nowhere near the 1,000+ threshold. Most small WordPress stores never qualify for behavioral modeling, which means they see gaps where modeling was supposed to help.

And it gets worse. According to USENIX Security research and CNIL data, 60% of EU visitors reject cookies when consent banners present accept and reject options with equal prominence (USENIX/CNIL, 2024). Dark patterns that bury the reject option are being regulated away. Legitimate consent banners drive higher rejection rates. Higher rejection rates mean more reliance on modeling that most stores can’t access.

Basic vs. Advanced: The Setting That Determines Your Data#

Consent Mode comes in two flavors, and the difference is critical.

Basic Consent Mode respects consent strictly. When a user denies consent, no data is collected. No cookies are set. No pings are sent. From GA4’s perspective, that visitor doesn’t exist.

Advanced Consent Mode sends anonymized, cookieless pings even when consent is denied. These pings don’t identify individual users—they’re aggregated signals that feed behavioral modeling. Without these pings, modeling has nothing to learn from.

According to Plausible Analytics research, sites using Basic Consent Mode lose approximately 50% of their tracking data when users deny consent (Plausible Analytics, 2025). With 60% of EU visitors declining cookies, that’s 30% of your total EU traffic completely invisible.

If you configured Consent Mode at all, you probably configured Basic mode because it seemed more privacy-respecting. Advanced mode sounds aggressive. Basic sounds safe. But Basic mode combined with a sub-threshold traffic volume means you’re flying blind.

You may be interested in: First-Party Data for AI: Start Now, Win Later

How to Verify Your Consent Configuration Is Actually Working#

Open your browser’s developer tools. Navigate to your site. Open the Console tab. Type dataLayer and press Enter. Look for consent-related entries.

You should see something like:

{
  "event": "consent_update",
  "analytics_storage": "granted",
  "ad_storage": "granted",
  "ad_user_data": "granted",
  "ad_personalization": "granted"
}

If you don’t see consent events in the dataLayer, your banner isn’t transmitting signals. If you see consent events but they never update after clicking Accept or Reject, your integration is broken. If the dataLayer shows nothing related to consent, GA4 has no idea whether your visitors consented or not—and will assume they didn’t.

You can also check GA4’s Real-time reports while browsing your own site. If consent is working, you should see your own session. If it’s not working and you’re in the EEA, you’ll be invisible to your own analytics.

The Permanent Data Loss Problem#

Here’s what makes this enforcement particularly painful: there’s no retroactive fix.

Data from periods when your consent configuration was broken is gone forever. Google doesn’t store it somewhere waiting for you to fix your setup. The events were never collected. The sessions were never recorded. When you finally fix your consent integration, you start fresh from that moment forward.

If your consent broke on July 21 and you fix it on August 21, you have a one-month gap in your data. No year-over-year comparisons for that period. No attribution data for campaigns that ran during that time. No understanding of what happened to your business for those 30 days.

Every day you wait is data you’ll never recover.

Why Server-Side Tracking Changes This Equation#

Browser-based tracking—including properly configured Consent Mode—depends on JavaScript executing in the visitor’s browser and consent signals being properly transmitted. There are dozens of points where this can fail: ad blockers, browser extensions, JavaScript errors, misconfigured consent plugins, CDN caching issues.

Server-side tracking captures events at the server level before they ever reach the browser. When a WooCommerce purchase happens, the event is recorded server-side regardless of what’s happening in the visitor’s browser.

This doesn’t mean you can ignore consent. GDPR still applies. But server-side tracking gives you a compliant first-party data collection system that doesn’t depend on complex client-side consent integrations working perfectly.

Transmute Engine™ captures events from WooCommerce hooks and routes them server-side to GA4, Facebook CAPI, and other platforms simultaneously—from your own subdomain as a first-party server. The consent decisions still matter, but the data collection doesn’t depend on JavaScript consent plugins talking correctly to GTM talking correctly to GA4.

Key Takeaways#

• July 21, 2025 enforcement was silent: Google began requiring Consent Mode V2 signals for all EEA/UK traffic without mass notification. Sites without proper integration lost 90-95% of European data overnight.
• Banners ≠ signals: A visible cookie consent banner is not the same as properly transmitting consent signals to Google tags. Many WordPress consent plugins require manual integration setup.
• Modeling thresholds exclude small stores: GA4’s behavioral modeling requires 1,000+ daily events from both consenting and denying users for 7 days. Most small WooCommerce stores never qualify.
• Data loss is permanent: Events not collected during non-compliant periods cannot be recovered. Every day of broken configuration is a day of lost data forever.
• Server-side reduces consent complexity: First-party server-side tracking captures compliant data without depending on complex client-side consent integrations working perfectly.

Your data is disappearing every day your consent configuration stays broken. Fix it now—or accept that you’ll never know what happened to your business during the gap.